Vallery was joined on the first team by teammate Dillon Hollin, a senior center.
Vallery was also named to the American Football Coaches Association Division III First Team, Associated Press Little All-America First Team, and the North Coast Athletic Conference Defensive Player of the Year.
Wittenberg finished 12-1 this season. Its only loss came against Wisconsin-Whitewater in the Division III tournament. Wisconsin-Whitewater beat Mount Union in the championship game.