Springfield fire station reopens after push from union leaders

The city initially announced it would re-open the shuttered fire station on Aug. 7 due to staffing and equipment issues.

Credit: DaytonDailyNews

A police and fire station shuttered earlier this year by the city of Springfield are reopening this month amid pressure from local unions.

Fire Station No. 5 opened on Saturday — less than two weeks after the city announced plans to postpone its reopening from July 1 to Aug. 7 due to staffing and equipment issues — after calls from union leaders for it keep the promise it made to voters who expected coverage to resume after an income tax increase was approved at the polls in May.

“We’ve been doing everything we can to respond to the concern that we said the station was going to open,” Springfield Mayor Warren Copeland said. “While this will be an issue in terms of a budget expenditure, the decision was made that we need to as much as we can reassure people that we were going to do what we told them we were going to do when we voted on the levy.”

The city embraced the importance of honoring its commitments during the recent levy campaign, Acting City Manager Tom Franzen said. The reopening of the fire station and the police substation is the first step in delivering on those promises, he said.

“Many factors, such as staffing levels, equipment availability, and financial resources, must be considered when determining the appropriate time to reopen both Station 5 and the Police Substation,” Franzen said. “Specifically, several options were considered for the timing associated with the opening of Station 5, as current fire staffing levels are down and issues with our equipment/fleet exist.

“Ultimately, the decision was made to open Fire Station No. 5 starting (Saturday) despite the strain on financial resources and equipment,” Franzen said.

The Springfield Police Division substation on Johnny Lytle Avenue will reopen on July 10 with one full-time employee stationed there, Police Chief Steve Moody said.

The reopening of the fire station will cost the city about $3,000 per day in overtime, Springfield Fire Division Chief Nick Heimlich said — meaning it will cost more than $100,000 during that time period.

The fire station on Commerce Road and the police substation were both closed on Jan. 1 to save money as the city failed to pass a tax increase last November.

The city told voters it would reopen the stations in July, although elected officials and city staff told the Springfield News-Sun this week that no July 1 date was promised as part of its levy campaign for a .4-percent income tax increase that would generate $6.7 million annually.

“We never made any promises in our materials to the public about a July 1 opening,” Springfield City Manager Jim Bodenmiller said. “We always said we wanted to open them as soon as possible.”

The “blessing in all of this” is that the levy passed, he said. The city intends to keep its commitments to taxpayers, Bodenmiller said

“We’ll absolutely be keeping our promises to the citizens,” Bodenmiller said. “We absolutely intend to keep our commitments.”

Heimlich told the city commission at its June 20 meeting the city wanted to delay the reopening of Fire Station No. 5 until Aug. 7, when a group of 10 new firefighters were set to join its ranks.

However, that decision upset local union leaders who believed the city broke its promise to residents during its levy campaign. Response times in both the area around the closed station and throughout the city have increased since it closed earlier this year.

“At the end of the day we believe they’ve done the right thing,” said Andy Rigsbee, President of Springfield Professional Firefighters Local 333.

Delayed opening?

The city had considered the delay for financial reasons, Rigsbee said, but for him it was more about the safety of residents.

Earlier this week, city leaders told the News-Sun the fire station would operate only during peak hours in July until Aug. 7.

However, the city decided on Thursday night to make the station fully operational on Saturday — hours after the firefighters union posted a video on its Facebook page urging residents to contact city commissioners to keep their promise to reopen the station on July 1.

“We believe that emergencies do not occur at predictable times and the remaining time that there is no fire or EMS protection is a risk for the citizens of Springfield,” the post read.

Rigsbee doesn’t believe the post is what changed the minds of city leaders, but rather the ongoing conversation the union had about public safety.

“I think we’re moving in the right direction by focusing on public safety as our primary concern,” he said.

Heimlich told the News-Sun it was a more efficient use of taxpayer money to open the station in August.

“I believe that I made the recommendation that I thought was the best recommendation,” he said. “That has been revised.”

RELATED: Springfield police, fire struggling to recruit, retain employees

Response times up

Since Station 5 closed at the beginning of 2017, EMS response times near the station are up by about one minute and 15 seconds, data from the fire division shows.

The division is also projected to have over 1,000 more calls this year than 2016, Heimlich said.

That’s meant firefighters and paramedics are overworked during their shifts, Rigsbee said.

“It feels like it’s just nonstop and it takes a toll,” he said.

MORE: $100K cut to Springfield police, fire OT may mean slower response

While the time has increased, the fire division is reaching its goal for response times for EMS calls 80 percent of the time in that area, data shows. The benchmark for the division is 90 percent of the time, Heimlich said.

The partial coverage isn’t enough, Rigsbee said. It’s a safety issue, he said, so it’s worth the extra money.

“If we could schedule emergencies that might work,” he said, “but we can’t necessarily say when an emergency is going to happen.”

Residents near Station 5 are glad to hear it’s reopening.

“To have them reopen that and get here a lot quicker time, that would be a lifesaver for us, literally,” Evelyn Mercer said.

Paramedics saved Gary Saylor’s son’s life, he said. His son was born with a immunodeficiency disease that left him in need of an emergency bone marrow transplant, he said. When the doctor couldn’t reach Saylor by phone, paramedics arrived at his door to tell him of the emergency.

Saylor was in favor of the tax levy, but his trust in city leaders is, “iffy,” he said.

Still, he said he wouldn’t mind a delay in reopening the station.

“It’s OK,” he said. “Things happen, things get changed all the time.”

Police staffing

The Johnny Lytle substation will reopen with one officer due to limited staffing No police activities have been held at the substation since it closed earlier this year, Moody said.

RELATED: Officials, union leaders in Springfield debate longevity pay

“It’s a one-man show and until we get our numbers back up, it’s going to remain that way,” Moody said.

The division will not run Bike Camp this summer and is focusing on hosting National Night Out on Aug. 1. The Springfield Citizen’s Police Alumni Association will also be hosting events in the building, he said.

The city charter requires the Springfield Police Division have up to 124 employees, but with the promise of six new officers to form a Safe Streets Task Force, the number is now essentially 130 police officers.

The Springfield Police Division has about 115 employees, which includes five new hires in training and other people who are out with injuries — meaning about 108 officers are currently available for duties.

“The men and women of this department are doing the best they can, but we need more manpower,” Moody said. “We’re in competition with other communities and they’re seeing less people turn out for civil service tests as well.”

The department is losing talented officers to other departments who have better pay and benefits, said Chris Armstrong, the president of the Springfield Police Patrolman’s Association, which represents about 90 police officers.

“We’re so far behind everybody else that we can’t retain good people,” Armstrong said.

Of 41 departments in central and southwest Ohio last year, the Springfield Police Division had the fifth-lowest top-level pay at about $58,000 annually, according to State Employee Relations Board contract records. The top-level pay at other departments in the region, included Whitehall at $87,000 and Kettering at $84,000 annually.

Any increase in pay for officers would have to be negotiated through collective bargaining, Moody said.

With the amount of time it takes to train new employees, Armstrong believes it could take up to a year to fill the remaining vacancies and get the Safe Streets Task Force up and running.

It’s also difficult to attract lateral hires, Armstrong said, because many of those people are applying for jobs at higher-paying departments with lower call volumes. The lower-paying departments are typically village police departments, which are mostly part-time.

“They’re not even qualifying for laterals,” he said, “They’re having to come off of the civil service exam.”

The city also requires new hires to attend the Ohio Peace Officer Training Academy in London, a resident program which separates people from their family, Armstrong said.

“It’s a large deterrent for some people,” he said.

Moody expects to have some form of the Safe Streets Task Force operating next year, he said. Hiring is always a struggle, Moody said, because there are so many agencies looking for qualified officers. The division must stay positive and work to recruit the best employees it can, he said.

“We’re all fighting for the same people,” Moody said. “It’s a tough job. We’re trying to do the best we can.”

Records room

Earlier this year, two civilian employees who processed prisoners coming into the jail were laid off. When one of the remaining civilian employees went on vacation, a police officer temporarily filled in, Armstrong said.

“Part of that promise was to put more police officers on the street,” he said. “I don’t know how you’re going to put more police officers on the street while we’re filling non-sworn personnel positions when there are vacancies. … They’re no longer there and they’re obviously essential employees because they need them.”

The officers who performed clerks duties were assigned to the crime scene and property units and are involved with the Automated Fingerprint Identification System, Moody said.

“They’re looking at quality control of prints and photographs taken at book-in,” he said. “They need to know the whole sphere of what clerks do at book-in. … It was not an officer off of the street.”

The records department was short-staffed before the levy passed, said Springfield Local Police 52 representative Robyn Barnhart. The union represents seven records clerks and traffic control at the police division. It has lost four people this year, including two due to layoffs.

After the levy passed, the records division has been even shorter, Barnhart said.

“It’s passed now, they got the money, we need to give the services back,” she said.

Moody intends to fight to get those jobs back or hire new police service clerks, he said.

“They’re a needed employee here at the police division,” Moody said.


UNMATCHED COVERAGE

The Springfield News-Sun provides in-depth coverage of important city issues, including recent stories on the passage of the city’s income tax issue and the heroin epidemic.

BY THE NUMBERS

$3,000: Amount of overtime costs the City of Springfield will spend per day to operate Fire Station 5 until Aug. 7.

.4: Percentage of income tax increase Springfield voters approved in May from 2.0 percent to 2.4 percent.

1,000: Increase in calls the Springfield Fire/Rescue Division expects to see in 2017 compared to 2016.

About the Authors